Are Divorce Settlements Always 50/50?

Are Divorce Settlements Always 50/50? | The Divorce Negotiator  | Divorce Financial Settlement Mediation  | Financial Consent Orders | Pension Sharing on Divorce

One of the most common questions couples ask when they separate is whether everything will simply be split down the middle. The short answer is no. Many settlements do end up close to an equal division, but there is no automatic 50/50 rule in England and Wales and some settlements are very different.

This guide explains where the idea of a 50/50 split comes from, why it is only a starting point and the main reasons a settlement may depart from it.

Where the 50/50 idea comes from

In a case decided in 2000, White v White, the House of Lords said that a proposed division should be checked against the "yardstick of equality". In other words, an equal split is a useful starting point for testing whether an outcome is fair, but any departure from it needs a good reason.

Since then, fairness on divorce is usually approached by looking at three broad principles:

  • Needs. What each of you, and particularly any children, reasonably needs to live on, including housing.
  • Sharing. The idea that assets built up during the marriage are the product of a joint effort and are generally to be shared.
  • Compensation. In a small number of cases, recognising that one of you gave up a career or earning opportunity for the benefit of the family.

Why many settlements are not 50/50

When deciding what is fair, the court must take into account a list of factors set out in the law, including:

  • the income, earning capacity and other resources of each of you, now and in the foreseeable future
  • the financial needs and responsibilities of each of you
  • the standard of living during the marriage
  • your ages and the length of the marriage
  • any physical or mental disability
  • the contributions each of you has made, including looking after the home and the children
  • in rare cases, the conduct of either of you where it would be unfair to ignore it

The welfare of any children under 18 is given first consideration.

Weighing up these factors often leads to a division that is not equal. Some of the most common reasons are set out below.

Housing needs

In many cases there is simply not enough to go round. Where the assets are needed to rehouse the children, the parent with whom they mainly live may receive a larger share of the equity. In most cases needs come first and sharing only becomes relevant once both of you can be properly housed.

Differences in income and earning capacity

If one of you earns much more than the other or has a far greater ability to raise a mortgage, a larger share of the capital may go to the other to balance the position. A difference in pensions can be dealt with in a similar way.

Assets from before the marriage or from inheritance

Assets one of you brought into the marriage, received as an inheritance or acquired after separation may be treated differently from those built up together. Whether they can be kept outside the division depends on how they have been used. Where they are needed to meet either person's needs, they may still be taken into account. You can read more in Ring-Fencing Assets in Divorce Settlement: A UK Perspective.

The length of the marriage

After a short marriage, particularly one without children, a settlement may aim to return each of you broadly to the position you were in before. After a long marriage, an equal sharing of the assets is more likely to be seen as fair.

Contributions

Contributions to the family are not judged only in financial terms. Looking after the home and the children is generally treated as just as valuable as earning the income. Only in very rare cases will one person's contribution be treated as exceptional enough to justify a larger share.

Conduct

Many people expect that the reasons for the breakdown of the marriage will affect the settlement. In practice the court very rarely takes conduct into account. It is usually limited to behaviour that has had a significant financial impact, such as deliberately wasting or hiding assets.

Looking at the whole picture

A settlement should be judged as a whole rather than asset by asset. One of you may keep the house while the other keeps a larger share of the pension or savings. What matters is whether the overall outcome is fair in your particular circumstances.

Reaching your own agreement

You do not have to divide everything equally if you both agree on something different. However, any agreement needs to be approved by the court in a financial consent order and the judge must be satisfied that it is fair. Where the division is not equal, the reasons need to be clear from the paperwork. You can read more in our article What is Form D81?.

How The Divorce Negotiator can help

We help couples look at their whole financial picture and reach a settlement that reflects their own circumstances, whether or not that is an equal split. Once you have reached agreement, we draft the consent order and supporting court papers, so you do not need to instruct a solicitor separately.

  • Mediation and drafting in one place. Your settlement and the order that makes it binding are handled together.
  • Telephone and video. We help couples anywhere in England and Wales.
  • Experience. We have been helping couples reach financial settlements since 2017 and have dealt with hundreds of cases.

Frequently asked questions

Does it matter whose name the assets are in?
Not necessarily. Assets built up during the marriage are often treated as shared, whichever of you owns them.

Will the person who earned more get more?
Not simply because they earned more. Caring for the home and children is generally treated as an equal contribution.

Does the reason for the divorce affect the settlement?
Very rarely. Conduct is only taken into account in exceptional cases.

Can we agree a split that is not 50/50?
Yes. The court will still need to approve it as fair, so the reasons should be clearly explained in the paperwork.

Talk to us about your settlement

If you would like help reaching a fair settlement, get in touch for a free initial conversation.

Get in touch